Votes & Actions
SOURCE: Transcript (Unofficial)
| Motion | Result | Moved / 2nd |
|---|---|---|
| Consideration and action to approve the consent agenda with the following items: Approval of the minutes from the regular meeting held on August 17th; Approval of the following personnel elections: Nicole Coutu, Elizabeth Fowler, Mitch Ouellette, Helen Pelletier, Shelby Santor, and Mary Catherine Short; Approval of the donation from Dirigo Reads; Approval of all needed transfers for current and prior year deficits as part of the FY26 closeout process. |
Passed
Unanimous
|
Feller, Smith |
| Consideration and action to approve Policy JIJC-R: Rules and Regulations for Personal Electronic Devices (Second Read). |
Passed
Unanimous
|
Richardson, Risch |
| Consideration and action to accept as a first read, Policy BEDH: Public Participation at Board Meetings. |
Passed
Unanimous
|
Feller, Smith |
Meeting Summary
- Start of School Year Update: The Superintendent provided a comprehensive update on the start of the 2026-2027 school year, highlighting summer projects like secure vestibules at Skillin and Dyer, the relocation of Kaler staff, and the onboarding of new leadership. The report also covered the successful launch of the new cell phone policy at secondary schools, with the administration addressing parent safety concerns.
- Public Comment: School Board Candidates: A significant portion of public comment was dedicated to candidates running for at-large school board seats. Stephanie Edwards, Carl Parsons, and Ishmeel Daniels introduced themselves, outlining their platforms which included fiscal responsibility, teacher retention, transparency, and long-term planning.
- Public Comment: Community Concerns: Citizens raised concerns about bullying prevention, the need for a later middle school start time, the accuracy of district surveys, and the safety of portables. Several speakers also addressed the upcoming elementary reconfiguration and the district's budget.
- FY26 Budget Closeout and Fund Balance: The Finance Committee reported that the district is projected to close the FY26 budget with only a ~$1,000 deficit, a significant improvement from earlier projections. However, this leaves the district with virtually no fund balance, a situation Member Richardson and several public commenters described as concerning and irresponsible, especially with potential facility emergencies looming.
- Policy Updates: Cell Phones and Public Participation: The board unanimously passed the second read of the new rules for personal electronic devices, formalizing the 'away for the day' policy. They also held a first read for changes to the public participation policy (BEDH), which proposes eliminating the practice of yielding time to other speakers and setting a 10:00 PM meeting end time, sparking debate during public comment.
- Committee Reports: The Buildings & Grounds Committee reported on progress with the middle school solar array, contingency planning for the aging Skillin Elementary boiler, and the design phase for the South Portland High School Athletic Complex. The Policy Committee advanced the cell phone and public participation policies.
Detailed Proceedings
Note: Transcripts are generated from video auto-captions. While highly accurate, they are non-official and do not meet State Archivist record-keeping requirements.
-
Call to Order and Roll CallThe meeting is called to order, and the roll is taken.
-
Chair's Report (DeAngelis)Chair DeAngelis announces the next regular meeting on October 14th, a board retreat on September 21st, and two upcoming public forums on elementary reconfiguration.
-
Student Representative Report (Lizeth Rios Blas)Student Representative Rios Blas reports a smooth start to the school year across all levels. She notes the successful implementation of the new cell phone policy at the high school and updates on adult education programs.
-
Superintendent's Report (Dr. Atkinson Duina)Dr. Atkinson Duina provides a detailed overview of summer work and the start of the school year. She highlights new elementary leadership, pre-K expansion, grant applications for secondary schools, and major projects by the operations and technology departments.
-
Cell Phone Policy Safety Update (Dr. Atkinson Duina)The Superintendent addresses parent concerns about safety related to the new cell phone policy. She explains that safety experts and local police agree that phones can be a distraction and hindrance in emergencies, and outlines the district's communication protocols.
-
Board Discussion on Superintendent's ReportBoard members ask clarifying questions about the superintendent's report.
-
Asks which staff members are using the new digital time cards.
-
Inquires about the status of middle school grant applications and the value of those grants. She also raises concerns about special education staffing vacancies in light of the recent reduction in force.
-
Clarifies that all impacted support staff from the reduction in force were offered positions. She states the current vacancies are similar to previous years and are a persistent challenge in the special education field.
-
-
Enrollment Report (Dr. Atkinson Duina)The Superintendent reports current enrollment at 2,739 students. This number is down slightly from the last report but remains stable compared to October of the previous year.
-
Public CommentThe first public comment session features several candidates for the at-large school board seat, union representatives, and community members discussing a range of topics including the budget, bullying, and school start times.
-
Introduces herself as a candidate for the at-large school board seat. As a parent and former teacher in the district, she emphasizes thoughtful fiscal responsibility, supporting staff, and improving communication and transparency.
-
Speaking as a school board candidate, he advocates for long-term planning for stability, exploring new revenue sources beyond property taxes, and ensuring a careful, considerate process for elementary reconfiguration.
-
Speaking on behalf of school employee unions, she asks what the district is doing to address bullying at all school levels, referencing a student who spoke at the previous meeting.
-
Introduces himself as an at-large school board candidate. He positions himself as a blue-collar parent who will ask common-sense questions and push for genuine transparency, communication, and diversity.
-
A parent of four, she expresses excitement for new leadership and asks for an update on the proposal for a single middle school start time, noting the health recommendations for later start times for adolescents. She also questions the potential for bias in AI-generated district surveys.
-
A school librarian, she speaks against the proposed policy change to limit public comment, arguing it restricts intellectual freedom. She also notes inequities in the current one-year elementary configuration.
-
Introduces herself as a candidate for City Council. She expresses a desire for more regular collaboration between the City Council and the School Board, particularly around the budget process.
-
-
Board Response to Public CommentChair DeAngelis and Superintendent Atkinson Duina respond to questions raised during public comment. They confirm committee meetings are public, promise a future report on anti-bullying efforts, and state they are meeting with the DOT about middle school start times.
-
Finance Committee Report (Claire Holman)Member Holman reports that the FY26 budget is closing with a minimal overage of about $1,085, which is excellent news. She notes the upcoming annual audit and the ongoing process of setting financial encumbrances for the new fiscal year.
-
Board Discussion on Fund BalanceMember Richardson expresses grave concern that while the budget is balanced, it leaves the district with no fund balance, which she views as an irresponsible financial position. Chair DeAngelis and the Superintendent argue against asking the city for a fund balance transfer, stating the district should manage its own finances and that the city remains a partner in case of a true emergency.
-
Policy Committee Report (DeAngelis)Chair DeAngelis reports that the committee is bringing forward the second read of the personal electronic device policy and the first read of proposed changes to the public participation policy.
-
Buildings & Grounds Committee Report (Daniel Feller)Member Feller reports that the middle school's solar array is generating surplus electricity, and a contingency plan is being developed for Skillin Elementary's aging boiler. He also provides an update on the high school athletic complex project, which is in the design and permitting phase.
-
Consent Agenda ApprovalThe board unanimously approves the consent agenda, which includes meeting minutes, several personnel appointments for one-year-only positions, and a book donation from Dirigo Reads.
-
Vote on Policy JIJC-R (Cell Phones)The board holds the second and final read of the policy on personal electronic devices. Member Richardson expresses her joy at hearing reports of a peaceful and serene atmosphere in the schools since implementation.
-
Vote on Policy BEDH (Public Participation)The board holds the first read of proposed changes to the public participation policy. The changes include adding time for interpreters, eliminating the ability to yield time to another speaker, and establishing a 10:00 PM hard stop for meetings.
-
Public CommentThe second public comment session focuses heavily on the district's financial situation and the proposed changes to the public participation policy. Speakers also raised questions about Kaler's assets, screen time, and portable classroom safety.
-
Questions how the large budget deficit was reduced to just $1,000 and argues that this outcome, leaving no fund balance, shows it was foolish not to raise taxes slightly more. He urges the board to act in the school department's best interest, not out of fear of the city council.
-
Echoes concerns about the lack of a fund balance to handle emergencies. He strongly opposes the proposed elimination of yielding time during public comment, arguing it curtails necessary dialogue from union reps and others on complex issues and reflects a lack of trust in the community.
-
Asks on behalf of the Kaler community where items such as furniture and equipment from the closed school have been relocated. He requests an itemized list or a way for the community to find out where these assets went.
-
Expresses concern over his 52% property tax increase over four years and the district's history of material weaknesses in its audits. He asks if account reconciliations are now occurring monthly to prevent budget overspending and financial surprises.
-
Argues that the school board cannot solve the city's affordability crisis through budget cuts alone. He advocates for working with the City Council to address root causes like daycare costs, rather than repeatedly cutting school resources.
-
Requests a detailed class-by-class enrollment breakdown and asks for guidelines on classroom screen time. She also re-raises concerns about the safety of portable classrooms and asks what is being done to foster a more inclusive environment in the middle school lunchroom.
-
-
Board Response to Public CommentThe board records several questions for follow-up. Finance Director Abigail Keshin comes to the podium to address financial questions, confirming that monthly reconciliations are a work in progress and a major focus for her new team.
-
Board CommunicationsBoard members share announcements and reflections. Topics include the need for an AI policy, thanks for a local music festival, information on child investment accounts (Trump Accounts), and self-introductions from incumbent candidates running for re-election.
-
AdjournmentThe meeting is adjourned.