Budget Workshop III

Thursday, March 28, 2024
6:00 PM · City Hall Community Room
Votes & Actions
SOURCE: Transcript (Unofficial)
Motion Result Moved / 2nd
To approve the FY25Superintendent’sBudget.
Passed Unanimous
Schen, Kinney
To approve the revised 2024-2025school year calendar.
Passed Unanimous
Schen, Ratliff
Meeting Summary
  • FY25 Budget Presentation: The Superintendent presented the final FY25 Superintendent’sBudget, highlighting a 5% school operating budget increase and a 3.82% mill rate increase. He noted these figures are competitive and fair to taxpayers, especially when compared to proposed increases in neighboring school districts.
  • Budget Challenges and Priorities: Key challenges in this budget cycle included enrollment variability, the loss of federal COVID-19 funds which supported 19 positions, and rising fixed costs. The administration focused on preserving excellence and fostering equity while navigating these constraints.
  • Extended Learning Opportunities (ELO) Program Update: The ELO program will continue at SOUTHPORTLANDHIGHSCHOOL through a new partnership with JMG. A JMG staff member will serve as a full-time "ELO Navigator," ensuring the program's continuation and aligning it with broader career-connected education goals after a two-year grant expired.
  • Athletics Program Equity Discussion: Board members discussed equity in athletics, focusing on removing financial barriers to participation. The conversation covered admission fees for events and the cost of sports-specific items, with a consensus that essential uniform items, such as swimsuits, should be provided by the district.
  • Unfunded Positions Review: The Board inquired about the costs of several requested but unfunded positions in the FY25 budget. The administration provided estimates, including $100,000 for a Director of Intervention and Mental Health and $175,000 for an additional pre-K classroom, should funds become available later.
  • FY25 Budget and School Calendar Approval: Following discussion, the Board of Education voted unanimously to approve the FY25Superintendent’sBudget. They also unanimously approved a revision to the 2024-2025school year calendar, extending the school year by one day to June 13, 2025.
Detailed Proceedings

Note: Transcripts are generated from video auto-captions. While highly accurate, they are non-official and do not meet State Archivist record-keeping requirements.

  • Call to Order and Roll Call
    The Board Chair calls the workshop and special meeting to order, followed by a roll call of the board members.
  • Agenda Update (Chair)
    The Chair announces an additional action item to approve a revision to the 2024-2025school year calendar. The change corrects an error by adding one day, making the new last day of school June 13, 2025.
  • Superintendent's Budget Presentation (Superintendent)
    The Superintendent begins his update on the FY25Superintendent’sBudget, outlining the budget development process and the difficult decisions required. He emphasizes the goals of preserving excellence, fostering equity, and being fair to taxpayers.
  • Budget Metrics and Comparisons (Superintendent)
    The Superintendent reviews the key figures of the budget, including a 5% operating increase and a 3.82% mill rate increase. He presents data showing South Portland's proposed increases are lower than those in several neighboring districts like Falmouth, Gorham, and Westbrook.
  • Health Insurance Update (Superintendent)
    An update is provided on health insurance costs, with the statewide range of increases being 1.5% to 11.5%. The district has budgeted for a 7% increase and is awaiting its specific rate, which will be known by April 10th and could necessitate budget adjustments.
  • Extended Learning Opportunities (ELO) Update (Superintendent)
    The Superintendent confirms that the ELO program will continue through a partnership with JMG, following the conclusion of a two-year grant. A JMG staff member will become a full-time "ELO Navigator" to coordinate the program and advance career-connected education.
  • Board Discussion on Budget and Programs
    Board members ask clarifying questions about the ELO partnership, athletic program equity, and costs of unfunded positions.
    • 0:20 Holman
      Expresses concern about the capacity of the JMG staffer taking on the ELO role and asks for the high school principal's perspective on how the change will impact programs.
    • 0:22 Scott Tomson
      The high school principal explains that the partnership is mutually beneficial, as JMG is seeking to redefine its curriculum for upperclassmen. He expresses great confidence that the new structure will be a positive outcome for students.
    • 0:28 Schen
      Raises an equity concern regarding admission fees for school events. She questions how the district ensures that students and families with limited financial means can attend and feel included.
    • 0:29 Joe Prince
      The Assistant Superintendent responds that the athletic department is exploring making events free for students while maintaining revenue. He also notes that the district already provides athletic passes to families who cannot afford them.
    • 0:33 Ryan
      Asks about equity in providing sports equipment, questioning what items the district provides versus what students are expected to purchase. She raises concerns about accessibility and potential cost barriers for students to participate in certain sports.
    • 0:36 Holman
      Argues that any item essential for participation, such as a swimsuit for the swim team, constitutes a uniform and should be provided by the district. She emphasizes the need to remove the barrier of a student having to ask for financial assistance.
    • 0:41 Holman
      Asks for the estimated costs of several requested but unfunded positions. She specifically mentions the mental health coordinator and an additional pre-K classroom.
    • 0:42 Joe Prince
      Provides cost estimates for the unfunded positions, stating a director-level position is about $100,000, a new pre-K classroom (including staff and supplies) is $175,000, and a teaching position is budgeted at $90,000.
  • Public Comment
    The Chair opens the floor for public comment on any item related to the budget process. No members of the public are present to speak.
  • Vote: Approve FY25 Budget
    A motion is made by Ms. Schen and seconded by Ms. Kinney to approve the FY25Superintendent’sBudget. The motion passes unanimously.
  • Vote: Approve Revised School Calendar
    A motion is made by Ms. Schen and seconded by Ms. Ratliff to approve the revised 2024-2025school year calendar. The motion passes unanimously.
  • Adjournment
    A motion to adjourn is made and seconded. The board votes unanimously to adjourn the meeting at 6:48 PM.