Votes & Actions
SOURCE: Minutes
| Motion | Result | Moved / 2nd |
|---|---|---|
| to enter into Executive Session pursuant to MRSA§405(6)(E) to consult with legal counsel |
Passed
7-0
|
DeAngelis, Ratliff |
| to enter into Executive Session pursuant to MRSA§405(6)(D) to consider a labor grievance |
Passed
7-0
|
Kinney, Ratliff |
| to deny the grievance that was addressed in the Executive Session and to direct the superintendent to provide written notice of the Board’s determination to the grievant and the relevant employee association |
Passed
5-2
|
Schen, Kinney |
| to approve the Consent Agenda items |
Passed
7-0
|
Schen, Ratliff |
| to approve the Director of Behavioral and Mental Health job description |
Passed
7-0
|
Schen, Ratliff |
| to approve the amendment related to the preparation for a possible facilities bond referendum for the school department |
Passed
7-0
|
DeAngelis, Kinney |
| to adjourn |
Passed
7-0
|
Ratliff, Kinney |
Meeting Summary
- Grievance Vote: Following an executive session, the board began the public meeting by voting 5-2 to deny a grievance and directed the superintendent to provide written notice of the decision.
- Recognitions: A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to recognitions, honoring music teacher Craig Skeffington for his induction into the Maine Music Educators Association Hall of Fame, the SPHS Robotics Team for a $5,000 grant from Consolidated Communications, and the SPHS Boys’ Track Team for their Class A State Championship.
- Community Partnerships Report: The administration presented a detailed report on Community Partnerships, highlighting the contributions of nearly 500 volunteers, numerous donations for student needs, and various career exploration programs like ELOs and partnerships with local businesses.
- Federal Funding Update: Dr. Prince provided an update on Federal Title Funding (ESEA), reporting a significant decrease of nearly $150,000 for the upcoming fiscal year, primarily in Title I funds, and outlined the proposed allocation of the remaining funds to support students at Kaler and Skillin schools, as well as multilingual learners.
- Facilities Bond Referendum Discussion: The board held a lengthy discussion on a potential facilities bond referendum. The Superintendent proposed projects for school security, deferred maintenance, and a major renovation of the high school stadium complex, including a controversial recommendation for an artificial turf field using specific recyclable and organic-infill products.
- Facilities Bond Resolution: After debate on the environmental and safety aspects of artificial turf versus natural grass, the board unanimously voted to direct the administration to prepare formal proposals for three separate bond referendums (safety, maintenance, and stadium) with a total cost not to exceed $17 million.
Detailed Proceedings
Note: Transcripts are generated from video auto-captions. While highly accurate, they are non-official and do not meet State Archivist record-keeping requirements.
-
Vote on GrievanceThe board voted to deny a grievance that was discussed in a prior executive session. The motion passed with a 5-2 vote, and the superintendent was directed to provide written notice.
-
Chair's Report (Ms. Ryan)The chair announced the next meeting date, welcomed new student representatives Angela Kabisa and Eliot Wertheimer, and reminded the public to vote on the school budget referendum.
-
Student Report (Angela Kabisa)The student representative congratulated the Boys' Track team on their state championship, noted the recent SPHS graduation, and shared updates from elementary and middle schools, including field days and end-of-year excursions.
-
Introduction of New Student Representative (Eliot Wertheimer)Superintendent Matheney introduced new student representative Eliot Wertheimer, who briefly addressed the board about his passion for helping students and his relevant volunteer experience.
-
Recognition: Craig Skeffington's Hall of Fame InductionThe board honored music teacher Craig Skeffington for his induction into the Maine Music Educators Association Hall of Fame. Several current and former students spoke about his positive impact on their lives.
-
A recent graduate, shared how Mr. Skeffington was an attentive and honest teacher who provided significant support to students, including allowing use of his classroom for practice.
-
Another recent graduate, spoke of Mr. Skeffington's passion for music and his ability to connect with students personally, making band class an engaging and supportive environment.
-
The board chair, a former student of Mr. Skeffington, shared a personal story about how he supported her in learning the trumpet, instilling a lifelong lesson in perseverance.
-
Mr. Skeffington briefly thanked the board and his former students for the honor, expressing his gratitude after 30 years of teaching in the district.
-
-
Recognition: SPHS Robotics Team GrantRepresentatives from Consolidated Communications presented a $5,000 grant to the SPHS Robotics Team. A team mentor thanked the company for the funds, which will support training and materials for the upcoming season.
-
Recognition: SPHS Boys' Track Team ChampionshipThe board celebrated the SPHS Boys’ Track and Field team for winning the SPHS Boys’ Track and Field Class A State Championship. The superintendent read the names of all team members and coaches, followed by remarks from student athletes and the head coach.
-
A graduating senior and team member, thanked the coaches and his teammates for a welcoming and strong team environment over his four years, noting that winning two state championships was a great way to end his high school career.
-
A graduating senior and team captain, thanked the school board for their support and highlighted the team's diversity as a key to its success. He expressed gratitude for the positive landscape the school has provided.
-
The Boys’ Head Coach, echoed the students' sentiments, emphasizing the team's camaraderie and inclusivity as true measures of success beyond championships. He also announced three athletes would be competing at the national championship.
-
-
Superintendent's Report: AnnouncementsSuperintendent Matheney announced the school district's participation in the upcoming Portland Pride parade and provided an enrollment update, stating the current number is 2,895 students.
-
Report: Community Partnerships (Gretchen McCloy & Bryna Latham)The directors of Community Partnerships presented their annual report, thanking the community for its support. They highlighted that nearly 500 volunteers were active in the district this year, and a new online training system has improved accessibility.
-
Community Partnerships: Donations and ProgramsThe report detailed numerous donations, including over 45,000 pounds of food from the Locker Project, winter coats from Operation Warm, and funds from Unum for playground improvements. They also thanked the elementary PTAs for their collaborative support.
-
Community Partnerships: Career ExplorationThe presentation covered career exploration initiatives, including career fairs at the middle and high schools, extended learning opportunities (ELOs) with partners like SMCC, and the Maine Career Badge program, which awarded $15,000 to students.
-
Report: Federal Title Funding/ESEA (Dr. Prince)Assistant Superintendent Dr. Prince reported on the upcoming year's federal funding. She noted a significant decrease of nearly $150,000, mostly in Title I, due to reduced state allocation and changes in charter school funding formulas.
-
Federal Title Funding: Proposed AllocationDr. Prince outlined the proposed use of the approximately $800,000 in total Title funds. The funds will support interventionists at Kaler and Skillin, a social worker, multilingual specialists, and professional development, among other supplemental programs.
-
Discussion: Facilities Bond Referendum Follow-upSuperintendent Matheney presented a follow-up to the May 30 workshop on district facility needs. He outlined three main areas for a potential bond: school security enhancements (~$3M), deferred maintenance like roofing (~$1M), and a major renovation of the SPHS stadium complex (~$10-13M).
-
Facilities Bond: Turf RecommendationThe Superintendent recommended moving forward with an artificial turf field for the stadium, specifically proposing IRONTURF for its durability and recyclability, and BrockFILL, an organic wood-based infill, to address safety and heat concerns. He stated the total project cost could approach $17 million with these higher-quality materials.
-
Board Discussion on Facilities BondBoard members debated the Superintendent's recommendation for an artificial turf field. The discussion centered on the environmental impact, long-term costs, and questions about the recyclability of plastic turf products versus the challenges of maintaining natural grass.
-
Expressed strong skepticism about the recyclability of plastic turf, calling it "greenwashing." She argued against covering fields in plastic and noted that even the NFL is moving away from artificial surfaces due to injury concerns.
-
Shared Ms. Holman's concerns about plastic and the need for more information on recyclability. She questioned whether the decision aligns with the city's "One Climate Future" goals and cautioned against choosing convenience over environmental responsibility.
-
Stated she was initially questioning but came around after learning that the proposed IRONTURF is made from recycled resin and is itself fully recyclable. She felt this aligned with the district's climate principles and made her comfortable supporting the proposal.
-
Argued that an artificial surface provides more equitable access for all students and the community, as it allows for far more use than a natural grass field that requires rest and is weather-dependent. She emphasized that the facility needs have been known for years and this is a path to a facility students can be proud of.
-
-
Committee ReportsThe chairs of the Finance, Buildings & Grounds, and Policy committees gave brief updates. The Finance Committee noted the district is in good fiscal shape and is addressing findings from the recent auditor's report.
-
Vote on New Job DescriptionThe board unanimously approved a new job description for a Director of Behavioral and Mental Health.
-
Vote on Facilities Bond ResolutionFollowing discussion, the board considered a resolution to direct the administration to continue work on a facilities bond. Ms. DeAngelis proposed an amendment to prepare three separate bond proposals (for safety, maintenance, and the stadium) instead of one, which passed unanimously.
-
Vote on Amended ResolutionAfter the amendment passed, the board unanimously approved the main, amended motion. This directs the administration to prepare three separate bond proposals with a total cost not to exceed $17 million for future board consideration.